top of page

The Dunning-Kruger Effect: Why 90% of Lucid Dreaming "Experts" are Wrong

Have you ever stumbled across a Reddit thread or Discord server where someone claims to have all the answers about lucid dreaming?

Dunning-Kruger Effect

They confidently assert that they can control every aspect of their dreams, solve complex problems, and even use lucid dreaming to enhance their waking life skills.

But are these bold claims backed up by scientific evidence? Or are they just another example of the Dunning-Kruger effect in action?


What is the Dunning-Kruger Effect?

The Dunning-Kruger effect is a cognitive bias where people with limited knowledge or competence in a domain greatly overestimate their own understanding and abilities.

A typical Dunning-Kruger Effect curve

It's a phenomenon that's especially prevalent in areas where success is hard to quantify objectively, like lucid dreaming.

People who have had a handful of lucid dreams might feel like they've unlocked the secrets of the universe, when in reality, they've just scratched the surface.


Real-World Examples of Overconfidence in Lucid Dreaming Communities

If you spend any time in online lucid dreaming communities, you'll quickly encounter examples of the Dunning-Kruger effect in action.

Reddit & Discord lucid dream "experts"

For instance, in one Reddit thread, a user claimed that they had "created the perfect technique for lucid dream induction ."

Another user on a Discord server boasted that they can "control every single element of their lucid dreams, down to the tiniest detail, in every single dream"

While these anecdotes might make for entertaining stories, they should be taken with a hefty grain of salt.

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and the current scientific understanding of lucid dreaming simply doesn't support these kinds of grandiose assertions.


The Allure of Being a Lucid Dreaming Guru

So why do people make these kinds of overconfident claims?

Part of it comes down to the allure of being seen as an expert in a fascinating and mysterious field like lucid dreaming. Who wouldn't want to be the guru who has all the answers and can teach others how to unlock the full potential of their dreams?

Lucid dreaming guru

However, the reality is that the science of lucid dreaming is still in its infancy. While researchers have made significant strides in understanding the basics of when lucid dreams occur and some of their measurable characteristics, there's still a lot we don't know about the nature and limits of dream control.


Why You Should Be Skeptical of Lucid Dreaming "Quick Fixes"

Another common manifestation of the Dunning-Kruger effect in lucid dreaming communities is the proliferation of "quick fixes" and "fool proof techniques" for achieving lucidity.

lucid dream skeptic

You've probably seen the ads or posts promising that you can "have lucid dreams tonight!" if you just buy this eBook or follow these five simple steps.

In reality, learning to lucid dream consistently takes time, effort, and a lot of trial and error.

There's no one-size-fits-all approach that will work for everyone, and anyone claiming otherwise is likely overestimating their own knowledge and abilities.


The Current State of Scientific Research on Lucid Dreaming

So what do we actually know about lucid dreaming from a scientific perspective?

Currently, the most robust findings come from sleep laboratory studies where researchers can measure brain activity and eye movements during lucid dreams.

lucid dream science

These studies have given us insights into when lucid dreams tend to occur (usually during later REM periods) and some of their measurable features (like increased activity in certain areas of the prefrontal cortex).

However, when it comes to the more sensational claims about lucid dreaming – like using it to enhance problem-solving skills or practice real-world tasks – the evidence is much more limited and inconclusive.

While there are certainly anecdotal reports of people using lucid dreams in these ways, we don't have the kind of rigorous, controlled studies that would be needed to verify these claims.


How to Avoid Falling into the Trap of Overconfidence

So how can you avoid falling into the trap of the Dunning-Kruger effect when it comes to lucid dreaming?

The key is to approach the topic with a healthy dose of skepticism and humility. Recognize that even if you've had some incredible lucid dreaming experiences, there's still a lot you don't know about the science and limits of dream control.

lucid dream trap

Be wary of anyone claiming to have all the answers or offering quick fixes for achieving lucidity. Instead, seek out reputable sources of information, like peer-reviewed scientific papers or books written by established researchers in the field.

And perhaps most importantly, don't be afraid to admit when you're unsure about something or when you've made a mistake.

The sign of a true expert is not someone who claims to know everything, but rather someone who is always eager to learn more and revise their understanding based on new evidence.


Are You a Victim of the Lucid Dreaming Dunning-Kruger Effect? A Self-Assessment Checklist

Use this checklist to evaluate whether you might be overestimating your own knowledge and importance related to lucid dreaming. Answer honestly:

  1. Do you find yourself making bold, confident claims about lucid dreaming techniques or outcomes without citing scientific evidence to back them up?

  2. Do you dismiss or downplay the opinions of established researchers or experts in the field of lucid dreaming if they contradict your own views?

  3. Do you believe that you have discovered a "secret" or "foolproof" method for achieving lucidity that no one else knows about?

  4. Do you feel that your personal experiences with lucid dreaming are sufficient proof of your expertise, even if they haven't been verified by controlled studies?

  5. Do you spend more time sharing your own opinions and theories about lucid dreaming than you do seeking out and learning from reputable sources of information?

  6. Do you become defensive or dismissive when someone challenges your ideas about lucid dreaming or asks for evidence to support your claims?

  7. Do you believe that you have achieved a level of mastery or control over your lucid dreams that goes far beyond what has been scientifically documented?

  8. Do you find yourself arguing with or dismissing the views of established experts or professionals in the field, failing to recognize that their years of rigorous study and research carry considerably more weight than your personal experiences or intuitions?

  9. Do you attempt to minimize the importance of scientific evidence or even resort to belittling established experts in an attempt to inflate the perceived value of your own opinions or status within the lucid dreaming community?

  10. Do you lack any formal experience, training or professional credentials in the field, relying solely on your own anecdotal experiences, popular books or blogs, and personal intuitions to inform your views on lucid dreaming?

  11. Do you prioritize your status and position within online lucid dreaming communities over cultivating a respectful humility and appreciation for the ongoing scientific study of dreaming?

  12. Do you think you're an exception and none of the above points could possibly apply to you? Or does this article make you feel defensive or angry?

If you answered "yes" to many of these questions, it's likely that you may be overestimating your own knowledge and expertise related to lucid dreaming.

This doesn't mean that your experiences or opinions are invalid, but it does suggest that you may benefit from approaching the topic with more humility and openness to learning from others.

Remember, true expertise in any field is characterized by a deep understanding of what is known, what is not known, and what remains to be discovered.

By embracing the complexity and uncertainty inherent in the study of lucid dreaming, we can all work together to build a more accurate and comprehensive understanding of this fascinating phenomenon.


Overcoming Lucid Dreaming's Biggest Problem

The Dunning-Kruger effect is a powerful cognitive bias that can lead us to overestimate our own knowledge and abilities, especially in complex and subjective domains like lucid dreaming. By being aware of this bias and approaching the topic with humility and skepticism, we can avoid falling into the trap of overconfidence and spreading misinformation.

Real lucid dreaming advice

Instead, let's focus on what the scientific evidence actually tells us about lucid dreaming, while keeping an open and curious mind about the many mysteries that still remain to be explored. With a grounded and rational approach, we can all take part in the incredible journey of discovering the full potential of our dreaming minds.

And the next time you see a post on Reddit, Discord, or any other platform confidently asserting ideas about lucid dreaming as if they are the final expert, remember this: the more confident the claim, the more likely you're dealing with someone suffering from the Dunning-Kruger Effect, with very little knowledge and even less humility. In other words, the opposite of an expert.


bottom of page